Monday, August 11, 2025

DEMANDING RESPECT

                                   
                      ( At Burlington, USA 2019) 

DEMANDING RESPECT 

I find many people demanding respect, quite often undeservingly. I firmly believe that the respect demanded is neither constructive nor lasting. People who demand respect often do so for various reasons, which could be ego, insecurity, status, power, cultural or social conditioning, misunderstanding and some previous experience. Demanding respect actively harms both the one demanding it and the one giving it. Both individuals know the respect is hollow, so the relationship becomes one of performance, not connection. In situations of 'demanded respect', the “giver” often plays along on the surface but feels no genuine admiration and tends to indulge in criticism behind the back of the person who demanded it. It removes the space for an honest and sincere dialogue. Killing sincerity, 'demanded respect' breeds hypocrisy and negativity over time.

OPINIONS OF HINDU SCRIPTURES  

In Hindu philosophy, the Upanishads reject the notion of 'demanded respect' Instead, they advocate for a respect that emerges naturally, grounded in ethical character, humility, and commitment to Dharmic living. The concept of Amantivam in the Bhagavad Gita (Chapter 13, Verse 7, and Verse 8) is nothing but the qualities of a wise person who does not seek undue respect or position, and who acts without arrogance, selfish ambition and pride. It praises the man endowed with the qualities of absence of ego or arrogance, humility, and lack of conceit. Some Slokas in Chapter 18 and Chapter 3 of the Bhagwad Gita also deal with this issue indirectly. Mahabharata also rejects 'demanded respect'. We know that Yudhishthira gains respect not by force or authority but by his adherence to truth and duty or Dharma, even under adverse circumstances. Contrary to this, Duryodhana seeks to demand respect through force and fear, but in the end, he loses his honour due to his actions being against Dharma.

Through its characters, Ramayana gives the most emphatic message on ‘demanded respect'. Sri Rama earns the respect of one and all, including his enemies, through his unwavering commitment to Dharma, truth, and compassion, while Ravana's pride and 'Demanded Respect' lead to his downfall.

Yoga-Vasishta teaches that respect earned through ego and demand is superficial and leads to suffering. According to it, true respect arises naturally when one transcends ego, cultivates humility, and realises his true self. The scripture clarifies that the respect demanded is Avidya, or lack of knowledge about one's real self. 

PHILOSOPHICAL OPINION

In Western philosophy, Friedrich Nietzsche has been the foremost critic of ’demanded respect'. According to him, ‘demanded respect’, especially when tied to authority or tradition, is a form of weakness or herd mentality. He believes that true respect is earned through strength and creativity, not demanded. Immanuel Kant says that demanding respect from others is not the real issue. According to him, the real issue is about giving it as a rational duty. Demanded respect contradicts Kant’s view of autonomous moral agents. Jean-Paul Sartre argues that respect must be authentic and freely given, tied to recognition of individual freedom and responsibility. He believes that forced or demanded respect’ undermines freedom and authenticity. Albert Camus has a sharp and clear perspective on 'demanded respect'. He writes believes it to be fundamentally void and even despicable. I quote Camus:-

 “There is nothing more despicable than respect based on fear.”

                                            

     ( Albert Camus speaking at the Nobel Prize ceremony)

 In Confucian philosophy, respect demanded without virtue disrupts harmony and is considered improper.

 GENERAL OPINION 

 Respect is never earned by force. It is built by a continuous reinforcement of fairness, empathy, trust and genuine feelings. In genuine respect, pride has no place. If you admire some person for his qualities, humility, behaviour, dealings, sincerity and empathy, you respect him automatically. Never does your pride spring forth and come in the way of your dealing with him.  Lack of respect brings pride in a relationship. In pride, you tend to dismiss and belittle other people. There is a disregard for the autonomy, boundaries and individuality. There is a 'Fall In' or a 'Fall Out' approach, both forming a part of the control mechanism. And no individual likes to be controlled. From pride springs forth its mischievous cousin, anger, though these look like different emotions. 

 Respect also implies recognising dignity, boundaries, and individuality, which foster trust and emotional safety. In any relation, respect is earned, not demanded. It is earned by investing humility, sincerity, attention, empathy and good conduct. Many individuals feel unsure about their worth, and they may try to force respect rather than earn it, because genuine respect from others feels uncertain to them. Merely being a relative, a friend or an acquaintance does not earn you respect. Those who keep demanding it without understanding the philosophy of respect get ignored and sidelined, so that  the other person is in a position to protect their emotions and energy. Quite often, a mere silence does its job in these situations. This silence also gives a message to the other person that his behaviour isn't worth your time. This method is more powerful than entering into a heated argument. Quite often, with your silence, the other person may also understand your boundaries. Beware of a persons who respect you because they consider you as a mere means to an end. This respect is never born out of genuine feeling or admiration.

And finally, ‘demanded respect’ is always fake and short-lived. Fear may force compliance, but never respect. Social obligations may force politeness, but they shall never spring forth genuine regard. Status imbalance may make people hide their real feelings to appear respectful, as disagreement may look unsafe to them. One needs to earn lasting respect. And lasting respect isn’t built in a single gesture.  It’s earned over time through consistent behaviour, integrity, and how you treat others. Respect extracted through intimidation isn't respect at all. It's coercion. On the contrary, respect is voluntary, grounded in dignity rather than submission.  

CONCLUSION 

 Respect demanded or sought by force, authority, or coercion is false, brittle, and detrimental. Across spiritual, philosophical, and literary traditions, true and lasting respect can be earned through empathy, humility, justice, and righteous conduct. Quite often, ‘demanded respect’ stems from pride or insecurity. It breeds anger, antipathy, and distrust. Unpretentious respect flows naturally to a person who acts with uprightness, empathy, and humility. Demanding respect undermines freedom, authenticity, and pleasant relationships. And respect is a mutual, voluntary recognition of dignity and worth, not a one-sided command or expectation. 

 

( Avtar Mota )


Creative Commons License

Wednesday, July 30, 2025

FOOD DELIVERY ROBOTS IN THE US

                                      
                                            


 FOOD DELIVERY ROBOTS IN THE US

 

In Jersey City, I saw a strange box moving with us. As it moved, it maintained a reasonable distance from us, stopped at the crossings, crossed busy traffic roads as the lights indicated a safe crossing signal and arrived at the restaurant that had engaged it for a food delivery assignment. Aanya, my granddaughter, told me this:-

“This is a robot.  Pablo, the man sitting at the concierge's place in our apartment block, calls it “Johnny”. It delivers food. The restaurant man puts food in it, and he orders it to move through a button. When it reaches the apartment block, people who ordered get a message. They also get the code of its lock. You have to come down to the place where Pablo sits, put the code and open the top to get your food. Then ‘Johnny’ goes back to the restaurant to take more orders. It can see and walk safely on roads, although it does not talk.”

 Aanya made it very simple for me. Later, I came to know many things about ‘Johnny’, the food delivery robot.

                                                     


Robots can be found throughout the restaurant industry serving up customised burgers, pouring perfect cups of coffee and even preparing fast-casual meals. Now they have arrived on the roads to deliver food. These robots are designed to enhance production and increase output while improving safety. A food delivery robot is an automated robot that helps in last-mile delivery. It is engaged in providing food parcels to end users without any human interaction. It is assembled with sensors that can detect obstacles and travel from one location to another. This robot product finds application in various end-user industries such as healthcare, retail, and logistics.

                                                   



These robots are going to render many thousands of people engaged in the food delivery industry in the U.S. and Europe idle. The reasons are obvious; they’re equipped with a combination of computer vision and GPS technology, moving at up to 4 miles per hour, and the day-to-day working costs nothing to the restaurant owners. These robots are capable of avoiding obstacles as they navigate towards the customer from a food establishment. These robots can deliver food and parcels up to 10 kg. I came to know that some bigger robots used by grocery stores can deliver up to 35 kg of load in one go.

                                             

 ( A food delivery Robot on the move in Jersey  City .....Mobile phone Video recorded  by Avtar Mota) 

In Jersey City, a restaurant owner told me this:-

“If anyone wants to use the robot, they need to download the delivery App. Once the customer orders the food of his choice, a PIN is generated, and the service begins. The users are able to track their deliveries and receive a message about the arrival of the ordered food. When the service robot arrives at the destination, the restaurant or the service provider sends a text message with a link. The recipient clicks the link to unlock the food delivery robot. Apart from families, a vast section of students and teachers on the campuses are using this robotic mode for ordering food. Over the last few years, food delivery robots have appeared in a number of cities and college campuses in the US.  The labour shortages, rise in the e-commerce industry, and the growing need for contactless services are driving the food industry towards delivery robots. Post-pandemic trends across the food industry for online ordering got accelerated with the extension of ‘work-from-home’ culture and consumers’ change in cooking habits. More and more people are joining the ever-increasing number of those who order online food. These robots have several benefits, such as accurate delivery and enhanced consumer experience. And I tell you that Uber Eats has signed an agreement to use sidewalks for automated robots to deliver food products or parcels to users. The food industry faces difficulties in finding employees, and it is here that an autonomous robot provides a great solution. These robots have a range of security features, including cameras, GPS tracking, alarms and the ability to be remotely piloted to ensure that deliveries or the robots themselves are secure while they’re out and about. There are also environmental benefits to consider. Most food delivery robots are electric, contributing to reduced carbon emissions compared to traditional vehicle-based delivery methods.” 

                                                                            

( Photo Source ...Internet )

I came to know that the small service robot has cameras embedded all around it, offering the robot a 360-degree view. The robot can even overcome a variety of obstacles to make its deliveries. It can climb curbs by lifting its wheels one by one until it makes its way up onto the sidewalk. It can also avoid collisions with people and navigate around obstacles. The robot is designed to make short-distance deliveries of small orders, the kinds of jobs that human delivery personnel don’t want. I also came to know that one of the most well-known autonomous robot companies in this area is Nuro. The company has signed an agreement with CVS Pharmacy, Domino’s, FedEx and Kroger. Other companies like Avride, Starship Technologies, Zipline, Serve Robotics, JD Logistics ( Chinese ), Ottonomy.IO, Kiwibot,  Cartken, Panasonic( Japanese ), and many more have also made an impact in retail, distribution warehouses and food delivery. As per information provided to me, the operating temperature of a standard food delivery robot can be in the range of -25°C to 55°C. The robots can run 10 to 12 hours on one charge. One can also engage these robots on rent, as buying a food delivery robot can represent a financial hurdle, especially for restaurants with limited profitability. The ADR industry is reaching a new level of maturity. Regulatory frameworks are becoming clearer. Robots are moving beyond college campuses into neighbourhoods, airports, and even supermarkets. I was told that the price of a food delivery robot can vary from 12000 to 50,000 US dollars, depending on various factors like size, load carrying capacity, battery life, and many other features. The price of a small basic model could be around 15000 US dollars. I was also informed that food delivery robots have arrived in many cities in Asia, including  Dubai in the  UAE.

 

( Avtar Mota )  


PS

( All photos by Avtar Mota, taken in July 2025 in Jersey City)


Sunday, July 20, 2025

THE STORY OF OTTLA KAFKA, SISTER OF FRANZ KAFKA

                                           
                              ( Ottla Kafka )
                        ( Parents of Franz Kafka )
                    ( Sisters of Franz Kafka )
                 ( Franz Kafka with sister Ottla ) 

THE STORY OF OTTLA KAFKA, SISTER OF FRANZ KAFKA.

 

Franz Kafka was born in 1883 and died in 1924, and some of his most famous works were published posthumously. It is believed that he destroyed some important manuscripts, fearing his readers might not like them. He also left instructions for all of his work to be burned after his death, which his friend Max Brod disobeyed.

 Kafka's writing style is distinct, unique, and, in a way, unusual.  It is characterised by its particular atmosphere and unsettling imagery. This is precisely the reason for the birth of the term "Kafkaesque", which is used to describe situations that are bizarre, illogical, and oppressive.

 Today, I will not be speaking about Metamorphosis, The Trial or The Castle or about the subject matter of his short stories. My mind goes to Ottla Kafka, his younger sister, for reasons which most of us don't know. In the US, I read a book on Ottla and also read some letters that Kafka and Ottla exchanged. The letters to Ottla reveal a new Kafka, hitherto unknown to the readers of his books. Through his letters, Kafka is unbelievably compassionate, helpful, and frequently humorous. As a brother, he provides a wonderful company to his sister Ottla.  Kafka wrote to Ottla for nearly 25 years, till his death, the only person in whom he had entire faith.

 Franz Kafka belonged to a German-speaking Jewish family originally from Germany, which had settled in  Czechoslovakia. Like Austria and many other countries of Europe, Czechoslovakia also had a sizeable population of German-speaking people. Kafka's father was a rich businessman of Prague. Franz Kafka had a complicated relationship with his father, which significantly influenced his writing.

 Kafka often felt alienated and oppressed by his father's domineering personality. Kafka disliked his parents because his father was autocratic and his mother supported him. Many critics believe that this lack of emotional support became pivotal in shaping the literary themes of Kafka. Apart from this, Kafka also had a deep-seated fear of inadequacy and societal rejection, often stemming from a difficult relationship with his father that also brought a sense of alienation in his personality. He also feared physical and mental collapse, which is reflected in his literary works, particularly in "The Metamorphosis". Add to that, he also struggled with social anxiety, insomnia, and other health issues, which further contributed to his anxieties. He also suffered repeated illnesses due to tuberculosis, which finally proved fatal for him. Antibiotics had not arrived in the world then.

Kafka also had ethical concerns about eating animals. Accordingly, he maintained a strict vegetarian diet. Franz was somewhat terror-stricken by his father's behaviour, a fact that made him seek emotional support from Ottla, his younger sister. Ottla encouraged her brother towards reading and writing when his father wanted him to join his business. Like her brother, Ottla also had a permanent conflict with her father. It was Ottla who temporarily housed her brother, Franz, in her house, so that he could write in peace and recover from his tuberculosis. Kafka never married.

 Ottla (real name Ottilie) was born in 1892. Franz's two brothers, Georg and Heinrich, died in infancy before Franz was seven. He had three sisters: Gabriele ("Elli") (1889–1942), Valerie ("Valli") (1890–1942) and Ottilie ("Ottla") (1892–1943). All three were murdered in the Holocaust of World War II by Nazi Germany after the invasion and occupation of Czechoslovakia.

 WHY GERMANY INVADED CZECHOSLOVAKIA

  In his book Mein Kampf (published in 1925), Adolf Hitler advocated the need for Lebensraum (living space) for the German people. Lebensraum meant occupying new lands to create one nation for the prosperity of the Germans. In a way, it was also meant to do away with some impositions put on Germany under the Treaty of Versailles that brought an end to World War I. Accordingly, Adolf Hitler (1889-1945), the leader of Nazi Germany, put all his energy into creating a 'Greater Germany', which included all German-speaking areas of Europe. Once in power from 1933, Hitler pursued an aggressive foreign policy that aimed to recover Germany's territorial losses following the Treaty of Versailles.

Hitler started the process of annexation of the Sudetenland, a part of Czechoslovakia which had a German-speaking population. The Munich Conference concluded that the Sudetenland territory would be ceded to Germany. In addition, Hitler would take over portions of Czechoslovakia provided he did not seek further expansion. The Czechoslovakian government was told that it could challenge Hitler to war, but it would do so without any support. In 1938, Hitler invaded Czechoslovakia. In the Munich Agreement of September 1938, Britain, France, and Italy agreed to recognise Germany's claim over the Sudetenland.  Possibly, this was an appeasement done by countries that never wanted to develop again a World War I-like situation in Europe. In March 1939, Hitler invaded and occupied the Bohemian and Moravian regions of Czechoslovakia, Slovakia became a German client state, and Hungary and Poland grabbed what was left of the old Czechoslovakia. Czechoslovakia was under German occupation from September 30, 1938, until May 8, 1945, with the end of World War II in Europe.

 The expansionist policies of Germany under Adolf Hitler were intertwined with Nazi racial ideology, which viewed certain populations as inferior and deemed them unfit to live in the territories that the Nazis coveted. This ideology fueled the Holocaust, the systematic genocide of European Jews. Hitler also invaded Austria. Hitler's aggressive foreign policy resulted in the outbreak of World War II in September 1939.

 During the Holocaust, the Germans and their collaborators killed approximately 263,000 Jews who had resided on the territory of the Czechoslovak Republic in 1938.

 THE DARING ACT OF OTTLA KAFKA

 Born on October 29, 1892, in Prague, Ottla was an independent, spirited woman. Despite being nearly a decade younger, she shared a deep bond with her brother Franz Kafka. Franz often entrusted her with his thoughts, once writing, "You are the only one who understands my chaos." Ottla defied societal norms, working on her family’s farm while Franz pursued his passion for writing. Their letters reveal a relationship filled with warmth and understanding.

With the encouragement of her brother and despite opposition from her parents, Ottla pushed through her own career choice and in 1920, she married a non-Jewish Czech (Christian). In the following years, Ottla gave birth to their two daughters: Vera (1921) and Helene (1923).

 In 1942, when the Holocaust began to tear lives apart, Ottla divorced her non-Jewish husband, Joseph David, to shield him and their two daughters from Nazi persecution. Her selfless act, however, placed her in even greater danger. Very soon, Ottla was deported to the concentration camp in Terezín, where she worked as a caregiver in an infant home. It was an orphanage which had Jewish children. On October 7, 1943, she volunteered to accompany a group of orphaned children from the Terezín (Theresienstadt) ghetto to the Gas Chambers. Ottla chose compassion over self-preservation and entered the Gas Chambers in Auschwitz with the children, refusing to abandon them. Survivor accounts tell of Ottla’s comforting presence on the transport—holding hands, singing Czech lullabies, and offering solace until the very end. Ottla and the children were murdered upon their arrival at Auschwitz.

Ottla’s letters to Franz, preserved by her daughters, provide a glimpse into her tender and resilient spirit. Ottla’s legacy lives on through her stories, which highlight unprecedented bravery and selflessness during one of history’s darkest periods. A memorial plaque at Kafka's family grave commemorates Ottla and her sisters, who were also killed in concentration camps.

                                         


 In the 2024 film," The Glory of Life"  (German: Die Herrlichkeit des Lebens), Alma Hasun has played the role of Ottla Kafka. Directed by Judith Kauffman, the film centres on the love story of Franz Kafka and Dora Diamant.

 

( Avtar Mota)

 PS

Approximately six million Jewish people were murdered by the Nazi regime and its collaborators during the Holocaust. Adolf Hitler, as the leader of the Nazi Party, was the central figure responsible for initiating and overseeing the persecution and extermination of Jews in Europe. The Holocaust was a systematic and organised act of genocide, driven by a hateful ideology that targeted Jewish people for their perceived race and led to the murder of nearly two-thirds of all Jews in Europe. 


Creative Commons License

Friday, July 18, 2025

APPLYING OWNERSHIP TO A RELATION IS THE KEY ISSUE



   
                                                             








OWNERSHIP IS THE KEY  ISSUE 

Sometimes I feel  :

" In love, the real issue is ownership.Applying ownership is also allowing the other person  the freedom to be what he is . Ownership is about recognising that each person's reality and feelings are valid, even if they differ from your own.In a healthy relationship, this sense of ownership brings mutual respect and support .It is the ownership that creates  a willingness to compromise and make sacrifices for the relationship's well-being. It is not  about possessing or controlling another person or his actions.In a relationship, ownership  implies understanding impact of one's spoken  words ,actions, emotions and  conduct  on  the other person . If one understands this simple fact, there comes a willingness to take responsibility for these actions, emotions and conduct .The blame game has no place in such relation  .

Ownership in a relation   brings trust and mutual respect  whereby individual demands become lesser, genuine and  realistic. It is similar to Hydropincs ,a  method in which  plants grow, flourish and bear flowers  without making demands for  soil or peat moss.

Applying ownership on 'as is where is basis'  works wonders. Should a plant own even a stone, it can not stop growing or blooming  .A rock remains a rock, a plant remains a plant  and one notices life , mutual dependence and flowers. 

Ravindra  Jain wrote....

"Boota pathraan  te ugdaa hai pyaar da
 Tainu vaasta hai dil di pukaar da
Le ja le ja sandesha sone yaar da.."
....,......
.
"A plant of love may even sprout out from a stone ."
Let him be assured   about this sincere cry of the heart , 
Carry this message to that loveable friend.)" 

(Avtar Mota)

PS
It is a random feeling . The reader is at liberty to agree with this feeling or disagree altogether. 


.Creative Commons License
CHINAR SHADE by Autarmota is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License.
Based on a work at http:\\autarmota.blogspot.com\.

Monday, July 14, 2025

THE LE MONDE : A HISTORIC NEWSPAPER PUBLISHED FROM PARIS


                                            

 

                                                 ( The New Headquarters of The Le Monde )
                                                     ( The New Headquarters of The Le Monde )
                                               ( The New Headquarters of The Le Monde )
                                                 ( The New Headquarters of The Le Monde )

                                                        ( President Mitterrand  and Mrs Gandhi)  

                                                            (Hubert Beuve Mery )                    
( President Mitterrand  reading The Le Monde )
                                                         ( Old Headquarters of Le Monde ) 
 
                                                 ( Jean-Paul Descombey with Le Monde)




THE LE MONDE: A HISTORIC NEWSPAPER 
PUBLISHED FROM PARIS


Le Monde and Le Figaro are two main French newspapers read in France. Both are being published from Paris. Le Monde has a good readership on account of its international news and a little centre-left editorial stance. Le Figaro, the second-largest national newspaper in France, after Le Monde,  has a centre-right editorial stance and is headquartered on Boulevard Haussmann in the 9th arrondissement of Paris. The Liberation (centre-left editorial stance), Le Parisien,  and Les Echos are also some prominent newspapers of France. Founded by famous philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre and journalist Serge July, Liberation started with a rather revolutionary stance following the protests of May 1968. Founded in 1942 as the newspaper of the French Resistance, Le Parisien (The Parisian) is dedicated to news of the Paris region is the best newspaper to follow if one is interested in Paris-related news and events. Les Echos newspaper is focused on business and economics. Founded in 1908, it is owned by the luxury goods conglomerate LVMH. The paper is known for its liberal economic stance and its readership of decision-makers. 
Published in French and English, Le Monde is one of the most trusted newspapers in France. It was also one of the first French papers to establish an online edition. In 2023, lemonde.fr served 20 million pages a day, reaching an audience of more than 500,000 subscribers. The English edition of Le Monde was started in 1969 and faced many difficulties and had to be closed down.  Since its re-launch in April 2022, the English edition of 'Le Monde' has offered a selection of articles that reflect the richness of the French editorial staff's journalism. Throughout its history, Le Monde has proclaimed its European convictions, but without making Europe the beating heart of its editorial line.

Founded by Hubert Beuve-Méry at the request of Charles de Gaulle (as Chairman of the Provisional Government of the French Republic) on 19 December 1944, shortly after the Liberation of Paris from the German army, it has published continuously since its first edition. Le Monde took over the format of Le Temps because the latter ceased publication in November 1942, shortly after German forces occupied the entire territory of France during World War II. Le Temps was the most important newspaper of the French Republic, particularly among the French political and economic elite.

Beuve-Méry rarely rubbed shoulders with politicians. He had little interest in dinners where the gossip of the times was gleaned, and didn't seek out the company of celebrities or the powerful. He was known as a firm, fair and fearless journalist in France.

Among many thousands of some VVIPs and important people, some prominent readers of the Le Monde could be listed as Pablo Picasso,  Albert Camus, Zhou Enlai, Jean-Paul Descombey, Andre Malraux, Charles de Gaulle, Francois Mitterrand, Nicolas Sarkozy and actor Jean-Paul Belmondo,  Mrs Indira Gandhi, JRD Tata, artist SH Raza and Shashi Tharoor. And in 1981, when Sorbonne University decided to honour  Mrs Indira Gandhi with the doctorate honoris causa, Le Monde brought out an Indian supplement for the event. And Mrs Gandhi surprised all at the Sorbonne by her flawless speech in French. During this visit, one of Mrs Gandhi's most off-beat programmes was a meeting with a select group of intellectuals at the gorgeous Pompidou Centre in Paris. Speaking fluent French, Mrs Gandhi mingled with them in a closed session to which journalists were not invited.

The 'Le Monde'  has lately moved to a New building that is also an architectural wonder. With the completion of its new headquarters, the 1,600 employees of the Le Monde Group have been brought together under the same roof in a generously arching building on 67-69 Avenue Pierre-Mendes-France in the 13th arrondissement of Paris. The previous headquarters were located at Boulevard Auguste-Blanqui, also in the 13th arrondissement. With its bold new plaza and semi-transparent outer skin, the new building creates connections to the general public and surrounding transit while also offering citizens and passersby a generous respite in the city. A translucent, dynamic façade and expansive public plaza express the building’s openness to its surrounding context. The  Snohetta Architects, a reputed company from Norway, designed the new building for the headquarters of Le Monde. The architecture of the new headquarters is guided by concepts of openness and transparency of the Norwegian society and reflects a unified Paris.

My friend Kamal Hak informs me this:-

"In 1993, Le Monde was perhaps the first European newspaper to carry a story on the exodus of the Kshmiri Pandits. I recall talking to its correspondent for a long time. It all happened due to the efforts of M.L. Kotru, who was the editor of the  Statesman newspaper then. The exodus story was immediately followed by the German newspaper 'Der Spiegel' with the help provided by M L Kotru ." 

And I am informed by a friend that M L Kotru paid a heavy price for supporting hapless Kashmiri Pandits at that critical juncture. The management at the Statesman newspaper fired him for his open support to the cause of the Kashmiri Pandits, who became the soft targets of the Pakistan-trained terrorists and their sympathisers in the Kashmir valley.Although the newspaper management  did not mention that he was being dismissed because of the Kashmiri Pandit story, but the Press Club of India was convinced that this highly reputed editor was dismissed , so suddenly and disgracefully only for his explicit support to the cause of the Kashmiri Pandits.

In Paris, I bought a copy of the newspaper in French from a bookstore for 5.50 Euros; a souvenir to carry back to India. It is cheaper monthly and quite cheap for online reading. The price of a digital subscription to Le Monde in English is €3.99/month for the first year, then reverts to €14.99/month. There is also a yearly plan for €43.99 for the first year, then €109.99 per year. I conclude this story of the Le Monde newspaper with a quote from Thomas Jefferson, former President of the United States of America:-

“Were it left to me to decide if we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.

( Avtar Mota )


Creative Commons License
Based on a work at http:\\autarmota.blogspot.com\.

Friday, July 11, 2025

THE VALIANT DOGRA SOLDIERS IN PARIS DURING WORLD WAR I

                                                                          
                           ( Wounded Dogra soldiers  convalescing in the Brighton Pavilion in the UK )


THE VALIANT DOGRA SOLDIERS IN PARIS

 

In the freezing month of December 1841, Wazir Zorawar Singh, the Dogra General, moved to Tibet to fight the Tibetans in the deadly conflict in the high Himalayas. Under the worst freezing conditions, he demonstrated the saying of Napoleon Bonaparte, ‘Offence is the best form of defence.’ His military campaigns helped in the process of assimilation of Ladakh and Gilgit-Baltistan into the erstwhile Dogra state in Jammu and Kashmir. We have another warrior, Brigadier Rajinder Singh Jamwal (MVC), who is also remembered as the Saviour of Kashmir in 1947. He was posthumously awarded the Maha Vir Chakra independent India’s second-highest military decoration. Maj. Somnath Sharma, another valiant Dogra who fought Pakistani infiltrators and saved Srinagar Airport, was the first recipient of India's highest military decoration, Param Vir Chakra (PVC). There are unending bravery stories of the valiant Dogras of Jammu. In the 1965 war, Dogra soldiers saw action on many fronts in J&K and won many battle honours. In the 1971 war, Dogra soldiers saw action in East Pakistan and the Khem Karan Sector. For their bravery in East Pakistan, 9 Dogra was awarded the battle honour of Suadih. The 5th Dogra Battalion fought in the Kargil War to capture Tiger Hill. The Dogra Regiment has not only contributed to the United Nations Peacekeeping Forces in the Gaza Strip, Korea, and Congo but has also contributed to providing various military observers in various peacekeeping operations around the globe. Under British command, the Dogra units served in numerous colonial military campaigns across Asia and Africa. They participated in the Second Afghan War (1878–80), where their familiarity with mountainous terrain made them effective against Afghan tribesmen. They were also involved in the campaigns in Abyssinia, Burma, and Tibet. In World War II, the Dogra Regiment was extensively involved across various theatres of war. The regiment contributed multiple battalions, which served in Burma, North Africa, Italy, and Malaya. Dogra troops fought the Japanese during the Burma Campaign, notably in the Battle of Kohima (1944) and the Battle of Imphal, which were turning points in halting Japanese advancement into India. Before Indian independence, the Dogras had to their credit two Victoria Crosses and 44 Military Crosses besides 312 other awards, including 2 Unit Citations.

                                                           

                                                                                                        
                                              ( Indian soldiers marching in Paris during World War I)                                                                        
                                                           ( General Wavell inspecting Dogra soldiers )                                          
       
(Scottish Highlanders and Indian Dogra soldiers sit side by side in a trench fortified with makeshift shelters during World War I. Captured in Fauquissart, France, this photograph from 9 August 1915 reflects the diversity and solidarity of the Allied forces on the Western Front.)
                                                                                  

DOGRAS IN WORLD WAR I

In Paris, I came to know that during World War I, Maharaja Partap Singh had sent the Dogra troops to fight alongside the British soldiers. The Dogra Regiment played an important role in World War I with its battalions deployed in Europe, Africa, and the Middle East.  The 41st Dogra regiment saw action in France during World War I (1914-1918), and this is mentioned in the books and literature relating to World War I. The Dogra and Sikh soldiers are remembered for their heroic deeds in the Battle of La Bassee, which was fought by German and Franco-British forces in northern France. The Dogra soldiers also joined the action in the Aubers, Neuve-Chapelle and Festubert areas of France. Lance Naik Lala (No. 501) of the 41st Dogra Regiment was conferred the Victoria Cross for his exemplary bravery in World War I. In France, the Dogra troops were commanded by Capt. PH Myles of the 41st Dogra Regiment, who was later killed in Action in *Mesopotamia in January 1916. In this war, the Ottoman Turkey had allied with Germany. The Dogra soldiers also saw action in Palestine and Egypt, supporting the British-led offensive against the Ottomans in the Sinai and Palestine Campaign. The Dogra soldiers joined British soldiers in the campaign against the Ottoman Empire in Iraq, where Indian troops bore the brunt of fierce resistance and logistical hardships. Throughout the war, the Dogra soldiers earned accolades for their bravery, and several were awarded the Indian Order of Merit and Distinguished Service Medal. Working their way through mangrove swamps, the Dogra soldiers surprised the European army with their bayonet charge, something not heard of in bush warfare. Many times, the Dogras led from the front. After protracted international discussions held mainly at Versailles ( France ), a peace treaty was signed between the Allied and Associated Powers (which included Great Britain, France, United States of America, Russia, Japan and some more countries ) and the  Central Powers ( which included Germany, Turkey, Austria-Hungary, and Bulgaria). After the war was over, many injured Dogra soldiers were admitted to special convalescent homes for the wounded soldiers set up in Paris and the UK by the British authorities. Most of the Dogra soldiers were sent to the Brighton Pavilion. The Royal Pavilion, also known as the Brighton Pavilion, was a former royal residence located in Brighton, England. The Royal Pavilion was transformed into the first Indian hospital in Brighton. The former palace, along with the Dome and Corn Exchange, was converted into a state-of-the-art medical facility in less than two weeks. New plumbing and toilet facilities were installed, and 600 beds were set up in the newly created wards. The  Brighton Pavilion was used for Indian troops from 1914 to 1916.

The wounded soldiers were visited by Queen Mary and King George V, who handed over some gifts to the injured soldiers. King George V and Queen Mary were also active in the war effort. The King first visited the Western Front in November 1914, and he returned five further times during the war. His engagements included meeting Allied heads of state, inspecting troops and visiting the wounded. Queen Mary felt she should accompany her husband, and her first visit to France was in July 1917, where she visited hospitals, aerodromes, nurses' hostels and casualty clearing stations. At home in Britain, they undertook similar visits to wounded and disabled soldiers, sailors and airmen in hospitals and convalescent centres; discharged soldiers and sailors were even invited to entertainments at Buckingham Palace. They were sent back to India only after all possible medical treatment. 

A major portion of the Jammu Kashmir State Forces under Maharaja Partap Singh participated in World War I (1914-1919). Their war trophies included the German insignia, the Brass Eagle and the German flag captured by the 2nd battalion, amongst other German artillery.  

An Army magazine on World War 1 wrote this about Dogra soldiers:-

 "More solid than brilliant, they are full of quiet and resolute courage when face to face with danger. Law-abiding and well-behaved, steady and resolute, though not showy of courage, their virtues shine forth in moments of peril when they will face certain death with a calm and determination to do before they die."

Another magazine published in India wrote this on Bastille Day in France:-

“The association of the Indian and the French Armies dates back to World War I. Over 1.3 million Indian soldiers participated in the war, and almost 74,000 of them fought in the muddy trenches to never return, while another 67,000 were wounded. Indian troops valiantly fought on French soil also. Their courage, valour, and supreme sacrifice not only thwarted the enemy but also significantly contributed towards winning the war.”

Perhaps the best compliment given to the Dogra soldiers  has come from Field Marshal Sir William Slim, who wrote this:-

“The Dogra proved themselves yet again a hardened and courageous fighter. Like his predecessors, he has been proud of his military heritage and has shown himself well-versed in the art of war. Nor did he fail to live up to his age-old reputation of combining courage with modesty and good manners as a gentleman should. I know from personal experience that in an army with many fine battalions, the Dogras have not merely upheld their brilliant reputation, but have added lustre to the pages of history of both their own regiment and of the Indian Army.”

 

                                                   ( A Dogra Rajput soldier in uniform, 1916)

The origins of the Dogra Regiment can be traced back to the late 19th century when the British Indian Army recognised the martial competency of the Dogra people. The regiment was initially raised as part of the Bengal Army in 1877, with the establishment of the 37th Dogra Regiment of Bengal Infantry. The 37 Dogra, 38 Dogra and 41st Dogra regiments saw action in World War I.

Enrolling in the army has long been the ambition and career motivation of the hill regions of the Dogras. Soldiering has not only become a substantial part of the economic structure of the Dogra Hills, but created social and cultural traditions built on the people's association with the army. After 1947, the Dogra Regiment became a prominent infantry regiment of the Indian Army. Dr Karan Singh, the last Maharaja of Jammu and Kashmir, wrote the Dogra Regiment’s regimental song, ‘Dikhi Lai Dogra Desh‘.General Nirmal Chander Vij, the 21st Chief of the Army Staff, was from the Dogra Regiment. And so were Lieutenant General M S Pathania PVSM, Major General Mohan Lal PVSM, Lieutenant General P N Hoon PVSM, AVSM, SM, Lieutenant General V K Jetley PVSM, VSM, Lieutenant General V K Sood PVSM, AVSM, PhD, Lieutenant General Sher Amir Singh PVSM, AVSM Lieutenant General H.S. Bedi PVSM, VSM, Lieutenant General Surjit Singh PVSM, AVSM, VSM, Lieutenant General S S Sanga PVSM, AVSM, VSM, SM, Lieutenant General J K  Mohanty PVSM, UYSM, AVSM, VSM, SM, ADC, Lieutenant General Jasbir Singh Dhaliwal PVSM, AVSM, VSM, Lieutenant General A K Singh PVSM, AVSM, VSM, SM, Lieutenant General G S Dhillon PVSM, VSM, YSM, SM, Brig Jagmohan Varma, SM, VSM, Lieutenant General Ranbir Singh AVSM, YSM, SM, ADC, Lieutenant General Jai Singh Nain AVSM, SM, ADC, Lt General VM Bhuvana Krishnan AVSM, YSM.

And in the field of sports and games, it produced six national-level players and twelve service-level players.

( Avtar Mota)

 

PS

The name Mesopotamia means "the land between the rivers" in Greek; meso is "middle" or "between" and "potam" is a root word for "river," also seen in the word hippopotamus or "river horse." Mesopotamia was the ancient name for what is now Iraq, the land between the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers. It has sometimes also been identified with the Fertile Crescent, although technically the Fertile Crescent took in parts of what are now several other countries in southwest Asia

 


Creative Commons License
CHINAR SHADE by Autarmota is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License.
Based on a work at http:\\autarmota.blogspot.com\.